Chair Dilemma

I've been on the hunt for a chair to complement the secretary desk that I scored during a "40% off the sale price" event at West Elm's Chelsea store.

Here's the desk (This picture is from the West Elm website, not my apartment. How great is that exposed brick, though?):



Here's chair option #1 (the "zebra chair," on sale for $49.95 at cb2.com):


Here's chair option #2 (the "envelope chair," on sale for $99.95 at cb2.com):

I'm leaning toward the zebra chair (it has more personality), but the envelope chair would match the desk perfectly...